Oil Carries a Few Externalities, Like Death and Dismemberment
I received the normal pushback on my recent piece praising electric transportation. In response, I make two broad points:
1) We are most definitely headed in the direction of clean energy, electric transportation (including small, urban commuter vehicles, e-bikes, mass transit, car-sharing, etc.), smart-grid, energy storage, and so forth. For a great number of reasons, we will not be burning coal and driving Hummers in 2050. One of these reasons is cost: the cost of renewables is falling, and will continue to do so.
My point is that each of these arenas will improve in something close to lockstep: cheaper and cleaner energy/storage and transportation. There are, of course, important questions about exactly how and when this will occur, and who’s going to make a buck in the process.
2) I call your attention to the variety of externalities of oil, which include war. I recently became aware that there are very scholarly, actuarial-style analyses of the value of a human life; see the discussion below if you think I’m kidding.
I’m not sure how you do this type of thinking without laughing. I just can’t imagine what Socrates, Jesus, or Buddha would say — but I can tell you very specifically what I say: our sending our children to fight and die over oil is an abomination. (more…)